of buyers expect a reply the same day
Impel, After the Lead Lands, 2026Where dealers lose buyers they’ve already paid for.
Slow replies, unanswered calls and follow-up that stops too soon. Here’s the evidence, and what fixing it looks like.
Most enquiries get a reply. Fewer get an answer.
Autotrader mystery-shops its top 1,000 retailers. Here’s what happened to every 100 enquiries, before a single follow-up was due.
Enquiries sent
To Autotrader's top 1,000 retailers
100
Got any reply
12% heard nothing by email or phone
88
Got a personal reply
The rest were generic
81
Had their question acknowledged
Fewer than half were answered within an hour
62
And these are the top 1,000 retailers.
The showroom closes. Buying doesn’t.
A third of buyer engagement happens out of hours. The older hourly breakdown below shows why evening enquiries deserve attention.
of buyer engagement happens out of hours
Impel, After the Lead Lands, 202624h
Enquiry timing · historical 2019 data
- 9am–6pm47.5%
- 6pm–11pm31.5%
- 11pm–2am7.5%
- 2am–5am7%
- 5am–8am3.5%
- 8am–9am3%
Enquiry timing: ClickDealer data, 2019. A different dataset and measure from 2026 buyer engagement.
ClickDealer enquiry data, 2019Give buyers a useful reply, while they’re still looking.
of car retailers didn't reply to an email enquiry at all
Autotrader Retailer Awards mystery shop, 2025Buyers decide slowly. Dealers give up fast.
Someone who isn’t ready this week may be ready next month. In the 2026 study, 34% of dealers stopped after one follow-up.
Research duration and dealer follow-up are different measures, not a promise that every buyer needs 88 days of contact.
One front desk. A clear next step.
01 · Missed calls
A proper callback handover
Keep phone enquiries and the next callback with the team. Live call answering is planned; it is not connected yet.
02 · Slow messages
An answer while the showroom is closed
Your website front desk replies from recorded stock. Marketplace intake needs a dealer connection; automatic WhatsApp and SMS are planned.
03 · Half answers
Vehicle details, not guesses
Stock details and official MOT history help answer vehicle questions. Valuations and finance questions go to your team.
04 · Forgotten customers
A clear next step
Suggested follow-ups your team sends, plus a three-day care task after a sale. Staff confirm MOT and service requests.
05 · No visibility
From first enquiry to handover
Track enquiries, bookings and outcomes. Keep signed agreements, invoices and recorded payments in the dealership workspace.
One forecourt. One system.
A fictional north London independent with around 60 cars. Not a client or a measured result.
Wrenfield Motors
Independent used-car dealer · ~60 cars
Most marketplace enquiries arrive after 6pm. By the time the team opens up, the buyer has already booked a test drive somewhere else.
- Website front desk answering from live stock; marketplace intake when connected
- Test-drive booking straight into the sales diary
- Part-exchange details collected for the dealer’s own appraisal
- Morning handover: every overnight lead ranked by intent
Modelled impact
+
extra cars a month
extra gross profit a year
Assumes 300 enquiries a month, £1,500 gross profit per car and conversion moving from 8% to 10%. Illustration only, not a client result.
North London
Quality used cars, checked in north London.
Browse 54+ carsFord Puma ST-Line
2021 · 24k mi · Petrol
£15,995
Kia Sportage GT-Line
2020 · 31k mi · Diesel
£17,450
VW Golf Life
2021 · 19k mi · Petrol
£16,295
Is the Puma still available? Could I see it Saturday morning?
It is. It has one owner and full service history. I've got 9:30 or 11:00 on Saturday. Which suits you?
Ford Puma ST-Line
£15,995 · booked by your front desk
Buying intent 86 / 100
Follow-up plan
Day 0 · Email
Your test drive is booked: Saturday 9:30, Puma ST-Line
Day 1 · Call
Team callback: collect Corsa details for your appraisal
Day 4 · Email
Draft for staff to send: would another appointment suit you?
What is one extra point of conversion worth to you?
Your numbers, your assumptions. We don't promise a particular lift. We measure it from your first enquiry and report it every week.
Extra cars a month
+6
Extra gross profit a year
+£108,000
Running total over 12 months · £9,000 a month
Find out what your enquiries are really worth.
Tell us about your forecourt and how you handle enquiries. We’ll review the details and get in touch to discuss whether Orqelis fits your dealership.